Fair 46.0°F Fair [Forecast] :: Saturday, November 21st, 2009
Vacation Info Wedding Info Kids/Parents NEW! Pets

Cape Cod Confidential

Dedicated to the history of Crime and Scandal in America's Vacationland - Cape Cod
Please visit these local CapeCodToday sponsors:
M.S. Construction & Remodeling
When quality & dependability make the difference and you are looking to have your project done right the first time, I'm the one to call! Specializing in exterior home improvement projects with over 20 years of construction experience. (Dennis)
John M. Janiak, Attorney at Law
With more than 30 years of private practice, John concentrates on all areas of real estate law, Wills and Trusts and the settlement of estates and organizes and provides advice to corporations and other business organizations.

Of Blogs and Wampanoags

Walter Brooks, who pays the bills for this joint, has been after me for years to write a blog. The Blogfather, as he is known, is very persistent.

He has no qualms about playing the guilt card. For years he has hosted my Web site, Cape Cod Confidential. He has always plugged my book by the same name. And like any organized crime boss, he remembers every favor he has ever done for you.

A few months ago, I asked him about setting up a blog for me, but on a topic that has little to do with Cape Cod. Walter wasn't interested. He is, if anything, single-minded and that has been the secret of his success. So behind his back, I created a new Web site and started blogging.

Thing is, I started to feel guilty. Walter had asked me to blog first.  And he's always been supportive of the stuff I write. When you add to the mix that I really like the old bastard (but not in a "wide stance" sort of way--not that there's anything wrong with that) I came to the realization I had to do something for him. We all have to do our part to help him make his next million.

I e-mailed Walter and asked him to set up this blog. For the first "issue," he threw up an article on the Tony Costa murders that I had written a few years ago. What you are reading now  is my first true blog entry. For as long as I can continue to do it, I'll post an article about crime and scandal from Cape Cod's past or present a historical perspective to current events on the Cape. Everything has happened before and nothing is new.

Take for example the current turmoil in the Mashpee Wampanoag tribe. Peter Kenney  has done a yeoman's job exposing the machinations within the tribe behind the proposed casino in Middleborough. But there have always been factions fighting within the tribe. Hopefully you all read Jack Sheedy's post about William Apess. When Apess arrived in 1833, the Mashpee tribe was in turmoil. Many had abandoned the traditional meetinghouse, which was controlled by a white Congregationalist minister named Phineas Fish, and instead were following a lay preacher named "Blind" Joe Amos. Head on over to Jack's article to find out what happened. Go ahead. I'll be here when you get back.

(While you're out you might want to pick up a copy of Jack's latest book co-written with Jim Coogan, Cape Cod Harvest.  Or better, click on the book link which will take you to Amazon. Please note I get a cut of the sale. I have to make money around here somehow.)

Mashpee MessengerWelcome back. A few years ago I arrived in Mashpee as a reporter. I was excited about the opportunity, because the town was home to the Wampanoags. I had grown up in Oregon next to the Warm Springs Indian reservation. A third of my school were members of one of the three tribes--Warm Springs, Paiute, and Wasco--that had been relocated to Central Oregon. I had immersed myself in their culture and their folklore, and was eager to do the same in Mashpee. But the first Wampanoags I met didn't seem very "Indian" to me. At least not the type of Indians I had known growing up. I began to wonder if these Wampanoags were like the kid I went to school with who would brag he knew all about being Indian because his great-grandfather was Cherokee. The kids from the Reservation would just look at him and shake their heads.

Then I attended a Mashpee selectman's meeting in May 1992. On the agenda was a nonchalant little item, "Shellfish Aboriginal Rights Discussion." Selectmen moved the meeting to the big room, so many people showed up. The audience was filled with Wampanoags. While they did speak of shellfish, most of the time they talked of being Indian in Mashpee. They talked of concerns over the inability to hunt, the effect of pollution on the rivers, and the blocking of ancient ways. After it was over, I was breathless. The same spirit that possessed those I had known in Warm Springs was also present that night. I felt ashamed that I had doubted them.

Little did I know that the events of that night would serve as a catalyst that today has resulted in the campaign to build a casino. But that is another story. And in the world of blogs, there will be plenty of time for stories.

 To read my 1992 article, click HERE for page 1, and HERE for page 2.

39 comments
Blog posts and comments are entirely the thoughts and ideas of the people who write them and in no way represent the views of CapeCodToday.com, eCape, Inc., or its employees or owners.

09/12/07 @ 9:02 pm
Jack Coleman [Member] writes:
Great post, Josh, very illuminating. And right on target about The Blogfather!
09/13/07 @ 6:54 am
EJ Albright [Member] writes:
Thanks, Jack.

-- Josh
09/13/07 @ 8:11 am
Buzz [Member] writes:
EJ,

I'm looking forward to your blogs. Many years ago, I worked in the news biz on the Cape. There have been several intriguing crime stories over the years and I thought I'd mention a few that come to mind. If you have any info/updates, I'd love to hear them.

Lt Chester Campbell MA State Police and the great marijuana heist. The elderly Cotuit housekeeper that was murdered...case never solved. Provincetown woman in the dunes... still haven't identified her.
09/13/07 @ 9:52 am
EJ Albright [Member] writes:
Buzz,

Because of potential libel issues, I focus on crimes more than 50 years old. This blog is probably a good place as any to discuss some of those crimes of more modern vintage.

With regard to the trifecta of crimes you mention, there isn't enough space in these talkbacks to go through all of them. I'll add them to the list. Maybe between all of us we can solve the ones that are still open. Nobody else seems to be able to do it.

--Josh
09/13/07 @ 10:23 am
Diana [Member] writes:
I know after a certain amount of time has passed it is really difficult to solve a case - if not impossible. Drudging up the past might feel like fun playing detective and all, but family members and friends could be re-traumatized by remembering the brutal death of a loved one.
I am curious to know about the book Costa wrote naming a friend as the killer - what is your source for this book?
All in all it's I think it's probably best to let these women rest in peace.
09/13/07 @ 11:53 am
EJ Albright [Member] writes:
Diana,

I disagree. Christa Worthington was solved because of media pressure. The Frances Carriere murder in Bourne was solved a quarter-century later because the Cape Cod Times took a renewed interest in the case.

Buzz mentioned the Cotuit housekeeper. I assume he means Herbert Reed, who was shot outside the Cotuit house he was caretaking in 1994. I think that is one case that deserves renewed attention.

The Costa book was quoted at length in "In His Garden," by Leo Damore. The book is out of print, but available through www.bookfinder.com.

-- Josh
09/13/07 @ 12:38 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
I agree, some cases need further investigation.
I sat through the trial for CW and feel it was not "solved." I think cases dated back to the 60's and 70's and even earty eighties seem like they would be difficult to solve today. Murder has no statute of limitations. When cases like CW continue, investigators and journalists can unknowingly psycholgically hurt people and damage the lives and repuations of "potential" witnesses and suspects. In some cases attorneys, law enforcement, journalists do this just for their own notoriety and financial gain, rather than to help solve a case for family and justice. In many instances family, friends, associates have moved on in their lives and ask not to get involved. I think we as journalist have an ethical obligation to respect everyone involved in a murder case. Sometimes law enforcement and journalists forget this or think solving a case is more important than respecting survivors.
09/13/07 @ 12:58 pm
crusader [Member] writes:
Diana,

I agree with you, but depending on what is written. I feel we as concerned citizens must keep questions out in the forefront, otherwise people will forget and not bother to solve these cases. It's unfortunate some people get hurt, but that's life. And if someone makes a false statement about them--it's their own duty to challenge it. The sooner the facts are brought out into the open--the sooner the innocent can get on with their own lives. I don't believe in profiting off a book of a dead woman before there is even a trial---with a DA who went along for the ride, some do. Sharing pre-trial evidence and photos to a profiteering writer SHOULD BE GROUNDS FOR DISBARRMENT. And if the W's family want to sue--they should go after the DA and that writer, not the trash company. Christa had a life that ended much too soon--and an innocent man is behind bars. What about their lives?
09/13/07 @ 1:04 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
Do you know how the case against the owner of the garbage company (Chris McCowen's employer)
turned out - they were suing him for $10 million?
09/13/07 @ 1:18 pm
bittersweet [Member] writes:
The "ethical obligation" we have is to let the innocent man go free! Geez, what are you talking about? Where's your respect for the guy they wrongly (and knowingly so, in my opinion...deliberataly so, as a matter of fact)locked up? He's supposed to sit behind bars for the rest of his life out of respect for the Worthington family? Even though he did not commit the crime? Not in this universe. Solving the case is the only thing that matters here. And you would think that's what the family would want. Not some fall-guy who's only "crime" was being with their family member. Man, if it was someone you cared about in that hell-hole,you would feel differently. And you would hope that people weren't as apathetic as you are about it!For crying out loud....wake up! It's in-justice in America right unde your nose.And this is a chance to do something about it. Not 30 years later, as it took Salvati.
09/13/07 @ 1:26 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
I think at some point people who know some parts of the case and not others need to let the justice system do their own work. I am concerned about how much some people get emotionally involved in cases when maybe what they really need to do is understand there are bigger forces at work here.
09/13/07 @ 1:40 pm
bittersweet [Member] writes:
Well. that would be ok, except.....look what happened the first time.... The justice system did it's work, and it was a horrible mis-carriage of it, in my opinion. So, sorry if i don't have much faith in the "bigger forces" at work. Unless someone can convince me other-wise. Then I would shut-up in a heart-beat!!! Because it is a real scary proposition-life behind bars. And it's even worse when they do it to someone who doesn't deserve it.....so sue me, I have to speak up against what i know to be wrong. And, just out of curiosity, how much of his life does Christopher McCowen owe to the bigger forces at work?
09/13/07 @ 1:50 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
It's an interesting case with a lot of players and since it is an old case I would think it is diificult to really get the facts and the truth. I think testing the external swab would have proven fruitful and following through on other key evidence. I just wonder why they didn't test such important evidence. I think some people may have been afraid of the outcome.
09/13/07 @ 2:03 pm
bittersweet [Member] writes:
Well, i agree with you on that, but just think of the outright sheer frigid horror of facing your life in there. That nightmare should be laid on the person or persons who did this, not Christopher McCowen. And the life of freedom that he/she/they are currently enjoying is not theirs to have. Which is worse, killing someone, or letting someone else pay for it? Allright...that's it, I'm taking your advice.No more. But if he gets mis-treated again, all of you who treat the prosecution with kid-gloves are going to see our gloves come off. It's going to be The McCowen Groupies vs.The Prosecution Pimps.right buzz?
09/13/07 @ 2:06 pm
Buzz [Member] writes:
bittersweet,

Christoper McCowen's DNA is found on the breast and in the vagina of Christa. The body is found in the hallway, the same place that Christopher initially said he had "consenual" sex with her. The guy had 5 different domestic violence charges with restraining orders from 5 differnt woman. The jury never heard that part and yet somehow in your mind he is an innocent man. Can you explain the DNA evidence for me?
09/13/07 @ 2:18 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
Bittersweet,
I really hate to say that there are bigger forces at work here, but I even remember a famous female, kind of radical feminist artist who lived in New York City conceding to some things being part of the world of men, like, oh yeah, look at them over there and what they are doing. I think sometimes it helps to look at it that way.
During the trial I felt pretty outraged and felt a sense of injustice about the fate of CM. I still do. I also know there is little to nothing I can do, so I just let it go and hope there is some justice. That is why I wonder about the man who owned the garbage company. He was another victim if CM was innocent, then so is the garbage company who employed him. Last I heard they (lawyer and Worthingtons) were suing him for 10 million. If you can follow the logic here it gets a little murkey for me at this point.
09/13/07 @ 2:33 pm
deltaman [Member] writes:
Hi, Diana. (Excuse my interruption here folks, but I cannot "legally" post again @ Diana's own "Building Bridges" blog, since no one else has since commented there. - Silly rule, imo, Blogfather…)

Anyway, the "quickening" as Fall is sometimes called, has just begun to weave magic colors into our landscape, so I'm really hoping to see a Part II to the Frugal Gardener's story, as you observe life slowly ebb from the garden. Perhaps we'll be further favored with a Part III next February, looking out from some snug nook, as snow billows & drifts into that space & you reflect on what was once there, then feel the 1st stirrings of some impatience for Spring's return... Whoops! Did I give away too much of the plot? (OK, baad pun.)

Seriously Diana I hope that you'll continue to share the view… (Wasn't it my turn to lead a cheer?) Check out her blog, folks - you'll be glad you did!
09/13/07 @ 2:42 pm
bittersweet [Member] writes:
Damn, that didn't last long!
1. Buzz, they had consensual sex on Thursday, when he called his boss and told him he was going there to remove her christmas tree.(it's on record-and the tree was still there, wasn't it? so, they must have had other things to do that day)
2. Whatever Mason said Chris said cannot be believed. (my opinion)
3. There were 2 other dna swabs that were not tested, of which the forensic pathologist Saferstein said were "important evidence sitting on the shelf."
And Diana, as far as them suing the trash company....that says volumes to me. The day after she was discovered, her father was in court laying claims on her property....does that rub you the wrong way as it does me? And this is not to bash anybody....it'sjust how I feel. And besides, no-one so much as says boo about bashing McCowen.
I personally think this whole case should be thrown out, and the DA's office and state police need to be investigated for some of the extremely suspicious activities that took place. What happened is wrong a thousand times over.
09/13/07 @ 2:51 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
What is imo?
09/13/07 @ 2:57 pm
deltaman [Member] writes:
"In my opinion" (I find fake humility unbecoming…)
09/13/07 @ 2:58 pm
Jack Coleman [Member] writes:
in my opinion, Diana. IMHO - in my humble opinion.
09/13/07 @ 3:16 pm
bittersweet [Member] writes:
deltaman...it's not fake humility! People have been threatened with liable for not using it! There are some blogs where you get "banned" if you don't follow the rules.
09/13/07 @ 5:08 pm
Buzz [Member] writes:
crusader,

She had his DNA on her breast..... are you saying she didn't shower for several days?
09/13/07 @ 5:12 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
DM - I am glad you appreciate the garden piece. I will try and keep everyone posted on any updates. There are wonderful light blue morning glories there today. And the asters are coming in many different colors.
BS - I think it's both good to be open about feelings and sometimes good to use discretion, especially on here - www.
JC - any news - where'd your blog go?
09/13/07 @ 5:56 pm
deltaman [Member] writes:
Diana, Im reluctant to appear as undermining your sage advice to BS (unfortunate contraction) since I think that it's pretty-much spot-on; still, one of my favorite blogs totally lays-waste to your theory & each new installment renders me incapacitated for a while… It's called boobsinjuriesanddrpepper.blogspot - you can easily add the "dot-com" if you decide to check-it-out.
09/13/07 @ 6:43 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
That's a funny blog dm, it seems to be full of humorous anectdotes about families and kids, kind of similiar to this in terms of it's a website with bloggers on it.
09/13/07 @ 6:43 pm
Peter Kenney [Member] writes:
I seem to recall being told by someone at the local cop shop that Mr. Reed, killed by a shotgun blast to the back, was the caretaker for a retired (or at least former) high level CIA suit.

AND - our boy Costa was writing about himself, or one of the other of his personalities he was trying to establish as a defense for his own actions. How do I know? Leo Damore's wife and mine were college room mates and I was his his best man many years ago in Falmouth. Very odd child, our Anton.
09/13/07 @ 7:46 pm
EJ Albright [Member] writes:
I come back and there are 27 comments. Wow. I don't think there are 27 comments in total for all the posts in my other blog. Walter keeps this place hopping, I'll give him that.

Of Christa Worthington, I have little comment. I tend to avoid what others are writing about. However, the investigation into her death got my book mentioned in TIME magazine. I guess that makes me no better than Flook or Peter Manso when his book comes out.

Figures, Peter, you would have a connection to Leo Damore. A few years ago I was getting ready to interview him when I heard about his death. Poor bastard. He was taking flak from all sides at the time.

-- Josh
09/13/07 @ 8:07 pm
Jack Coleman [Member] writes:
Not sure which blog you're referring to, Diana, I juggle a few.

Josh, I remember having the same reaction after learning of Leo's death. The late Bernie Flynn, who'd worked both the Costa and Chappaquiddick cases as a state police detective, recommended "In His Garden" to me but I couldn't get through it, too macabre. Leo's "Senatorial Privilege" is among the best books ever written about the Kennedys.
09/13/07 @ 8:10 pm
Diana [Member] writes:
At one point I read one that seemed devoted solely to CM trial.
09/13/07 @ 8:13 pm
EJ Albright [Member] writes:
Jack,

Bernie was one of the people out for Damore. As I recall he had sued him (successfully) for $50K for his help on the Chappaquiddick book. That was but one of a multitude of troubles Damore was having.

-- Josh
09/13/07 @ 10:01 pm
Jack Coleman [Member] writes:
Your recollection about Bernie's lawsuit against Leo is accurate, Josh. I remember the stories about it and was disappointed to see bad blood between them. Never met Leo unfortunately but Bernie was a regular at a restaurant where I tended bar in Falmouth years ago. One day we were talking about Chappaquiddick and I mentioned Jack Olsen's compelling theory that Kennedy wasn't in the car, as described in Olsen's book "The Bridge at Chappaquiddick," and Bernie said, I know all about that theory - I gave it to him.

Diana, the blog you're referring to is Cape Cod Murder. Yes, the focus of that one is pretty much limited to the Worthington case.
09/13/07 @ 11:16 pm
Mwalim [Member] writes:
Josh!

Great to see you back in print! I remember our first meeting was after my parody of your piece on Zachary's Pub. How goes it all?
09/13/07 @ 11:47 pm
keesuq [Member] writes:
Hi Ej. Thanks for taking the time to get to know and understand the tribe. Your words are interesting as most folks think natives have to be, look, sound and act a certain way. We are all unique; however it is the spirit that you fealt. The spirits are ancient ones. The spirit is the creator. The spirit is alive and well in Mashpee Wampanoags and in the land, trees,water, air, all four legged ones and in our hearts, mind body and soul! Thanks for sharing your experience with us and learning about us.

Nice words. Peace to you and yours!
09/14/07 @ 6:51 am
EJ Albright [Member] writes:
Jack, Bernie supposedly knew where a lot of bodies are buried on Cape Cod, or at least claimed he did. Never spoke to him, either.

Mwalim, Good to hear from you, although as I recall the Zachary piece you wrote was not necessarily flattering of our coverage. Or is my memory tricking me? Life's been very good, although I miss newspapering on the Cape. I almost made it back a couple of times, but negotiations with publishers fell short. "Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice ..."

keesuq, Thanks. My time in Mashpee was a particularly intense one as a reporter as it was during the second round of the David Mace shooting flap. Wrote a lot of stories about the Wampanoag.

-- Josh
09/14/07 @ 9:16 am
crusader [Member] writes:
EJ,

I am interested in knowing more about Leo Damore. As difficult as some sections of the book were to read, I think he was one of the best writers of our time. What impressed me was his unwavering thoroughness in his research, it was so rich in detail, not many writers today are as gifted or willing to put that much effort into writing true crime, in my opinion. Mostly what we read now is cheap sensationalism because it's what sells. Why did Bernie sue Leo? Did Leo write some things that were inaccurate? What else can you tell us about Leo Damore. It's unfortunate he died that way. I haven't read his other books, but plan on it.
09/14/07 @ 9:38 am
EJ Albright [Member] writes:
Sorry, Crusader. I know little about him. Sounds like Peter knew him, so maybe he can chime in.

He wrote for the Cape Cod News (now defunct), and through his relationship with Bernie Flynn, got the skinny on Ted Kennedy and Chappaquidick. This got him a book contract, but it never materialized. Instead Damore wrote a book about a Christian Scientist couple that were put on trial for murder because they refused medical treatment for their child. Then came In His Garden. He eventually did write the Chappaquidick book, mentioned above.

Here's an interesting bio of Damore (you have to delete the space):

http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/ USAdamore.htm

Click on the link to Mary Pinchot Meyer, which was what Damore was supposedly working on at the time of his death. Here's the link. Mind the gap:

http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/ JFKmeyerM.htm
09/14/07 @ 10:32 am
crusader [Member] writes:
thanks EJ,

Maybe Peter remembers Evelyn Lawson....can you tell me anything about her, Peter?
09/18/07 @ 11:54 am
cbetter [Member] writes:
Jack,
I'm a bit confused. Did Bernie Flynn ever write a book on the accident? You said that he was a regular in a restaurant where you bartended. As he has passed, did he have family or friends that he may have left unfisished writings/articles with?
Please visit these local CapeCodToday sponsors:
Curves of Cape Cod
Curves is a facility specially designed for women featuring a complete 30 minute workout. You can burn over 500 calories in one strength training workout! New 30 Day Diet Plan. Lose weight and keep it off! Five convenient Cape locations.
Cape Cod Center for Whole Health
Whole health education, hands-on services, & mind-body techniques, to empower you while encouraging optimum health! Special classes in reiki healing, crystal healing, ear candling, hypnotism and more! (Mashpee)
IMPORTANT NOTICE FOR COMMENTORS & BLOGGERS: CapeCodToday now requires a one-time validation of your account email. When logging in or registering for the first time, you will be emailed a link to click that will validate your email and complete your login. The link in the email must be clicked in the same session when you are logged into the site for security purposes (i.e. retrieve the email right away and do not close your web browser).

This is a one-time-only process (or if you change the email on your account), and will help CCToday keep out the spammers. If you cannot validate your email because it is invalid, and you are a legitimate user, feel free to contact us and we will update your account to your current email.

Please Login or Register to leave a comment. There are 3,356 registered commenters!

CapeCodToday requires readers register an account with us in order to post comments. Become a trusted commenter and receive the benefits of posting instantly throughout the site. It's quick and easy!

Please note: If you are a CapeCodToday registered blogger, you can use your blogger login. Your login for the blogs is separate from your CapeCodToday main site login (if you have one).

Previous/Next posts in this blog

About This Blog

ccclogo140_200Evan "Josh" Albright spent a decade on Cape Cod as a newspaper editor and reporter, and during that time he began researching what he thought would be a brief series of articles on the history of Cape Cod crime. Today he has written more than 150 stories and a book, Cape Cod Confidential: True Tales of Murder, Crime and Scandal from Pilgrims to the Present.

Email him here with tips or ideas for future stories. Visit his archive of Cape Cod crime and scandal here.

- site sponsors -


CCT Blog Tools

Login to comment or manage your blog:

Username: 

Password:     

Become a CapeCodToday Blogger!

Are you passionate about your community? Do you blog or at least harbor thoughts of doing so?

If so, CapeCodToday.com would like to host your blog on our CapeCodToday weblog publishing platform.

Blog Newsfeed

CapeCodToday uses standard web "newsfeeds" (RSS) to automatically update the latest blog entries in your browser or newsreader.

Use any of the links below in your newsreader or web browser to get "Cape Cod Confidential" postings delivered to you, or use the RSS icon in your browser's address bar.

RSS 2.0 Atom 0.3