Cape Cod Murder

A Dish Best Served Cold From Manso

Another book, another mauling of Cape and Islands District Attorney Michael O'Keefe.
Part Two of a Two-Part review of "Reasonable Doubt" by Peter Manso

It's probably too late, the damage to his reputation already too immense, but O'Keefe should probably avoid all contact with anyone who will ever write a book.

First came the catty snarling about O'Keefe from Maria Flook,  whose "Invisible Eden: A Story of Love and Murder on Cape Cod" appeared in the spring of 2003, little more than a year after Christa Worthington was stabbed to death in her Truro cottage.

The image of O'Keefe answering the door for Flook clad only in a towel in an apparent clumsy come-on was so indelible that it became the basis for a hilarious  image of O'Keefe on the cover of the Cape Cod Voice newspaper.

The image of O'Keefe allegedly answering the door for Flook clad only in a towel in an apparent clumsy come-on was so indelible that it became the basis for a hilarious Photoshopped image of O'Keefe on the cover of the Cape Cod Voice newspaper.

O'Keefe's disparaging remarks about Worthington in "Invisible Eden" as a promiscuous "equal opportunity employer"  and "slob" eager to bed nearly anyone prompted immediate scorn and anger. The Worthington family petitioned the state attorney general to take O'Keefe off the case, leading O'Keefe to apologize to them and claim he'd been misquoted.

For Peter Manso, battling O'Keefe nearly landed him in prison on trumped-up gun charges, eventually dropped, in what came across as a blatant, ham-fisted attempt to silence a critic.

In the course of writing his new book, "Reasonable Doubt: The Fashion Writer, Cape Cod, and the Trial of Chris McCowen," Manso learned that "my own phone records had been grabbed without a subpoena or court order the day after Christa's body was found," a decision likely made as a result of Manso receiving a phone call from a despondent Worthington cousin after her body was found.

O'Keefe's disparaging remarks about Christy Worthington in as a promiscuous "equal opportunity employer"  and "slob" eager to bed nearly anyone prompted immediate scorn and anger.

It wasn't just his phone records pulled by the DA's office, Manso learned, but also those of his wife and at least 45 others "obtained via demand letters to a compliant Verizon."

Three years after Worthington's murder, the case still languishing, investigators conducted a controversial DNA sweep in Truro,  advising donors that their cooperation was voluntary while also letting known that the names of those who did not cooperate would be added to a "special list."

Although it was a DNA match that led to the arrest of Christopher McCowen, her garbageman, it wasn't the DNA sweep that hauled him in. What the public didn't know at the time, Manso writes, is that "the majority of the 150-odd swab collected were never even turned in for analysis. Rather, the samples languished in DA Michael O'Keefe's office until Christopher McCowen was arrested in April 2005, four months after the sweep, more than a year after McCowen's DNA was collected. It, too, had sat on a shelf in O'Keefe's corner office while Truro trembled."

DA's office would evolved into a fiefdom over the Cape and Islands

Manso goes back decades in describing how the DA's office would evolve into a fiefdom over the Cape and Islands, with power far exceeding that held by earlier prosecutors.

O'Keefe succeeded the late Phil Rollins, a popular glad-handing pol who served as district attorney for more than three decades, and for whom O'Keefe worked as prosecutor for 20 years.

Rollins, in turn, had succeeded another district attorney, Edmund Dinis, whose career was derailed by a single case --his slap-on-the-wrist prosecution of  Ted Kennedy after a passenger in his car, Mary Jo Kopechne, drowned on Chappaquiddick in 1969.

At the time, the so-called "southern district" extended from Bristol County to the Cape and islands; in 1975, the more conservative Cape and Islands became a separate district with its own district attorney, thereby giving Republicans an advantage in controlling the office for decades to come.

Only two years into his first term, Rollins took the "unusual step" of assigning a state trooper to his office, according to Manso; "in time he assigned a dozen."

"The Crime Prevention and Control Unit -- CPAC -- vastly increased the DA's power by gutting traditional checks and balances," Manso writes. "On the Cape, CPAC was under the DA's thumb. State police had become the king's palace guards."

"A miasma of law-enforcement shortcuts running through the case like mold on a particularly smelly cheese."

Massachusetts state law also gives district attorneys jurisdiction over investigation of homicides instead of local police, a problematic arrangement. "In Massachusetts, murder is political because the cops are powerless," Manso quotes Cape journalist Jeff Blanchard. "If you call the state police or the locals, anywhere, anytime, they'll refer you to the district attorney."

With McCowen's arrest, O'Keefe finally had a suspect in Worthington's murder, one with weekly access to her property, a criminal record, restraining orders against him, and a DNA evidence proving physical contact with the victim.

In his dissection of McCowen's prosecution, Manso uncovered a "a miasma of law-enforcement shortcuts running through the case like mold on a particularly smelly cheese," all part of a post-9/11 culture he sees as paranoid on security and indifferent to civil liberties.

Running roughshod over the Fourth Amendment

Who was Anthony Smith? He was the son of Girard Smith, the elderly Truro man who saw a large dark truck or van speeding out of Worthington's driveway on the day before her body was found.

For example, lead state police investigator Chris Mason obtaining two vials of blood from deceased Truro resident Anthony Smith and "delivered to the crime lab for analysis without, it appears, a court order or family permission." Who was Anthony Smith? He was the son of Girard Smith, the elderly Truro man who saw a large dark truck or van speeding out of Worthington's driveway on the day before her body was found.

"Mason was covering all the bases, as he usually did, since he is a very thorough man," Manso writes. "But he ran roughshod over the Fourth Amendment in the process, displaying utter insensitivity to a parent's grief.  Smith, who lived with his father, the stubborn witness, had taken his own life."

After his detailed analysis of McCowen's trial, which was expected to last two weeks but dragged out five, largely due to defense attorney Robert George's doggedness, Manso turns at last to his nemesis, O'Keefe himself. A half-dozen other prosecutions under O'Keefe are found lacking, his fundraising practices and spending as DA called into question.

Manso's criticism of O'Keefe is vitriolic and withering --

The book which will keep DA O'Keefe awake for many nights to come. Buy it at one of these local bookstores or on Barnes & Noble here or on Amazon here.

The DA was smart, knew the law, and was as ambitious as anyone in local government. But he was a miserable man, childless and alone. His divorce had reinforced his innate misanthropy and his adolescent sexual longings. He'd been passed over for a judgeship while his ex-wife  was appointed to the district court bench. His drinking had accelerated to the point where, even as he targeted seventy-six-year-old "rapists," he was weaving in and out of mid-Cape bars, often during the late afternoon, unable to drive himself home. Worse, his choirboy upbringing had fostered an inflexible, black-and-white worldview that metastisized into the belief that he had a God-given right to make moral judgments. The agent of righteousness felt duty-bound to characterize Christa Worthington as a slut who'd take on the butcher, the baker, and the husbands of her friends, even as the fifty-seven-year-old harassed frightened teenage salesgirls amd took payoffs disguised as campaign contributions.

Kinda makes you want to shower, doesn't it?

It's worth noting that O'Keefe isn't alone in his take on Worthington -- turns out it's one of the few things he shares in common with Manso, who writes --

The Outer Cape's bohemian values played a role in Christa's life, but by her family's standards, she was normal. Promiscuity was in her DNA. She wasn't a bad or reckless person. She was a Worthington.

 As "Reasonable Doubt" hits the bookstores, O'Keefe faces possible indictment for his alleged role in political payoffs and illegal gambling on the Cape. O'Keefe has denied the allegations but they still hang over him, not yet resolved.

Suffice it to say, if O'Keefe ever finds himself in court as defendant and not prosecutor, Manso will be sitting up front taking notes, once again, his jaundiced eye not missing much.

Read Part One of this Review "Not an innocent man, but not a killer either" here.

Jack Coleman has been a reporter for several local newspapers including The Cape Cod Times. He covered the Christa Worthington murder trial for CapeCodTODAY.com and the New York Post. He is presently a regular contributor to Newsbusters.org.

Not an innocent man, but not a killer either

Manso's new book finally explains the Worthington murder
Part One of a Two-Part review of "Reasonable Doubt"

By Jack Coleman, Special to CapeCodTODAY.com

Author Peter Manso is implacable in seeking the untold story of our tarnished District Attorney.

It took nearly 10 years, but someone has finally explained the murder of Christa Worthington in a way that makes any sense.

That it should be Peter Manso in his new book, "Reasonable Doubt: The Fashion Writer, Cape Cod, and the Trial of Chris McCowen," comes as no surprise.

Manso's involvement in the case began on the night in January 2002 when he received a phone call from one of Worthington's relatives, stricken with grief after the body of her cousin was found by a former boyfriend.

More than three years would pass before police would arrest a suspect in the case -- Worthington's trash hauler, Christopher McCowen -- who also happened to be a man of color, thereby racheting up interest in the case exponentially.

The trial that followed in the autumn of 2006 riveted local residents and generated media attention unseen on the Cape and islands since an inquest into the death of Mary Jo Kopechne in 1969, in equally murky circumstances. 

In both cases, an end to legal proceedings didn't put to rest any number of persistent questions. And with the release this week of Manso's book, many people will be asking those questions again, at least those taking the trouble to actually read what Manso has written. And once people delve into this book, a compelling summer read, they won't be able to put it down.

Many people won't take the trouble, however, because they can't get past Manso's personality. "Abrasive" seems to be the adjective most commonly attached to him. As someone who's had my share of verbal tussles with the man, it's a description not always undeserving. But I doubt there is another person anywhere more knowledgeable about this case.

No one knows more about this case than the "other murderer"

It did not go at all as expected and veered into the surreal, Manso tells readers in his introduction --

 I began this project with the assumption that the Christa Worthington murder would be the basis for my "trial book" (every journalist wants to do a trial book), that it would take only eighteen months to complete, and that my involvement as the author would be no different from my involvement in the half-dozen other books I've written, even though I'd known Christa Worthington, my neighbor in the town of Truro on the tip of Cape Cod, Massachusetts, for more than a dozen years.

Like many assumptions, these proved false, largely because of what I found  while digging into the crime, its investigation by the Massachusetts State Police, and the trial I'd planned to cover in the style of the late Dominick Dunne, notebook in hand, memorializing courtroom events in a so-called objective manner. Instead, I would up lending assistance to the defense team and soon found myself in a great deal of trouble -- specifically (not to say surreally), hauled into court, where I was indicted on a series of felonies after voicing my belief, both in print and as a guest commentator on Court TV, that the Cape and Islands district attorney in charge of the case (and also the case against me) was an ambitious, racially insensitive politico who'd cut corners in the courtroom and during the three and a half years he supervised the police investigation.

The case against McCowen appeared strong at first. As Worthington's trash hauler, he'd had weekly access to her property. McCowen, 34 at the time of his arrest and hobbled by a borderline IQ, consistently denied to police that he had any physical contact with Worthington and claimed he'd never been inside her house.

Once a DNA match was established and McCowen was arrested, his story changed repeatedly during an interrogation lasting nearly seven hours. In its final version, McCowen admitted he'd had sex with Worthington, but it was consensual, and that he was at her house the night she was murdered, but a friend actually killed her.

McCowen's seemingly desperate claims were hardly bolstered by the revelation prior to trial of a half-dozen restraining orders against him from as many women, though at least some of these, the exact number open to question, filed in attempts to receive financial assistance from the state.  McCowen had also served time in prison for burglary auto theft, though his criminal record did not include incidents of violent crime.

McCowen's claim that Frazier killed Worthington did not seem all that unlikely.

Once McCowen's trial began in October 2006, the problems with the prosecution's case soon became apparent.  Other than McCowen's interrogation by police and the DNA evident proving physical contact with Worthington -- but not rape -- the case was circumstantial.

The murder weapon was never found, not a single fingerprint, hair or fiber of McCowen's clothing was found at the scene of the murder, and no witness had seen the crime, at least none willing to come forward.

During the trial, McCowen's claim that Frazier killed Worthington did not seem all that unlikely once the particulars of the night in question were revealed in court. McCowen and Frazier, along with a third friend, were bar-hopping on the night of Friday, January 4, 2002, two days before Worthington's body was found.

That the three young men got as far as Eastham, where Frazier got into a fight at a party, was also established in court. Manso reveals in his book what jurors and observers at the trial were not privy to -- that in July 2003, Frazier pulled out a knife and threatened two English summer residents at the Wellfleet pier.

Frazier was charged with  assault with a deadly weapon, a felony, Manso points out. The charges were later dropped after neither of the summer residents  appeared in court to testify. But why had they not? Manso writes --

Records from the victim/witness assistance unit of the DA's office show that Keir Kennedy-Mitchell and Blake Fisher were never contacted by the court or the O'Keefe office. Never. Not about the trial date or even that Frazier had been arrested and indicted. The omission was colossal.

"To date [Keir] has never received any correspondence from the U.S. courts or indeed any U.S. lawyers about this matter," Kennedy-Mitchell's  family retainer wrote to me in a May 2009 e-mail. Kennedy-Mitchell had "received no request formal or informal to attend as a witness in any hearing. ... He will be very happy to respond to any official request from the courts."

A troubling lapse on the part of the DA's office, to say the least.

The book which will keep DA O'Keefe awake for many nights to come. Buy it at one of these local bookstores or on Barnes & Noble here or on Amazon here.

That Frazier had allegedly planned to rob "a rich woman's house" in Truro with "lots of money, rare coins and jewelry" was revealed by a witness at the trial, further bolstering McCowen's claim.

Then there was the matter of blue and white clothing fibers found in Worthington's pubic hair. A video taken of McCowen, Frazier and Shawn Mulvey at a bar in Orleans showed Frazier wearing a blue and white sweater.

Another troubling aspect of the trial came from the testimony of a Worthington neighbor walking past her property in the early afternoon of Saturday, January 5, 2002, just over 24 hours before her body was found. The man testified that he saw a large dark vehicle barrel out of Worthington's driveway and that he caught a glimpse of its driver -- a white male in his late '30s or early '40s.

Add to this the medical examiner's conclusion that Worthington died 24 to 36 hours before her body was found -- in other words, right within the timeframe of an apparently panicked driver who could not be McCowen leaving her property -- and another hugely problematic element was introduced at trial.

During the trial, which I covered as a stringer for the New York Post and wrote about at this blog, I wondered if the blue and white fibers and unknown motorist might be enough to establish reasonable doubt among jurors.

In the end, McCowen's claims were more dubious than jurors were willing to accept and he was convicted of first-degree murder, rape and burglary. The jury was unable to render a verdict until one of its members was dismissed during deliberations after it was revealed in court that she had referred to media coverage of the trial, in violation of Judge Gary Nickerson's instructions to the jury, during a phone conversation with her boyfriend in jail.

McCowen's defense was handled by a skilled lawyer, Robert George, who'd been involved in high-profile cases before and approached this one in his characteristically brash manner. Like an outmatched boxer lasting far longer into a fight than expected, George punched so many holes in the case that many observers expected a hung jury to result.

But the disparity in resources between George and the district attorney's office was huge and his closing argument came across as scattershot. Manso writes here --

The defense lawyer's syntax had become garbled at times during his forty-five-minute address. And he's pointed his finger in too many directions instead of telling a single coherent story, which probably should have been the same story his client told over and over again during his interrogation: Jeremy Frazier killed Christa Worthington.

Speaking with Manso by phone last week, I asked him about his conclusion about George's closing argument -- if this is what he thought George "should have" told jurors, isn't Manso saying he believes McCowen is at least partially complicit in Worthington's murder?

"Nowhere in this book do I say McCowen is an innocent," Manso responded. "But I have my doubts that he would have been charged had he been white."

But if police were motivated by racism in their pursuit of McCowen, you'd think it wouldn't have taken more than three years to charge him with Worthington's murder.

After all, police first made personal contact with McCowen as a potential suspect in March 2002, two months after Worthington's death, with McCowen agreeing to provide a DNA sample in April 2002.

I came away from this book skeptical that a just verdict was rendered.

Three more years would pass before the state crime lab matched McCowen's DNA with that found in and on Worthington's body -- three years in which Republican district attorney Michael O'Keefe oversaw police investigation of the case, and with another Republican, Mitt Romney, controlling state offices such as the crime lab from the Corner Office. If this was a racially-motivated investigation, it moved at a glacial pace.

Also undercutting claims that McCowen was railroaded was the Supreme Judicial Court -- the same court to make Massachusetts the first state to legalize same-sex marriage, not incidentally -- unanimously upholding the verdict in December 2010.

Still, I came away from this book skeptical that a just verdict was rendered, and that alleged racism among jurors, the subject of a seldom-seen post-verdict hearing, affected their deliberations. 

In fairness to Frazier, the evidence that he murdered Worthington is decidedly flimsy -- it hinges on the claim of a man facing life in prison, McCowen, and physical evidence of it is non-existent.

Even so, Manso makes a strong argument that it's hardly unlikely, of Frazier as the predator that awful night in Truro, not McCowen, a man never lacking for female companionship.

Read Part Two "A Dish Best Served Cold" here.

Jack Coleman has been a reporter for several local newspapers including The Cape Cod Times. He covered the Christa Worthington murder trial for CapeCodTODAY.com and the New York Post. He is presently a regular contributor to Newsbusters.org.

Further allegations of juror bias surface in McCowen murder case

Further allegations of juror bias surface in McCowen murder case

In the letter, Manso writes that Miranda told him that Gomes, in the past, has said:
"I don't like black people";
"I don't like what black people have done to the Cape";
"Blacks are lazy";
"These niggers come down here and they think they can do what they want. They're making us look bad";
"I don't hang around with black people";
"All niggers do is rob people, kill people and deal drugs."New accusations of deep-seated racial bigotry have been lodged against a Cape Verdean juror who is at the center of an unprecedented post-verdict hearing in the case of convicted murderer Christopher McCowen, Lawyers Weekly has learned.

It is believed that Julia Miranda, the 74-year-old great-aunt of juror Eric Gomes, signed a sworn affidavit that, if true, could seriously undermine Gomes' credibility and further strengthen McCowen's bid for a new trial.

This development was brought to the court's attention by Peter Manso, a Cape Cod journalist whose yet-untitled Simon & Schuster book about the McCowen case is due out in the fall. McCowen, who is black, was convicted in 2006 of killing and raping Cape Cod fashion-writer Christa Worthington, who was white.

In a Jan. 14 letter hand-delivered to Superior Court Judge Gary A. Nickerson, defense attorney Robert A. George and Cape & Islands District Attorney Michael D. O'Keefe, Manso writes that he spoke with Miranda and another of Gomes' relatives at the courthouse on Jan. 11...  Lawyer's Weekly. 

______________________

Judge To Decide If Murderer Gets New Trial
McCowen Convicted Of Killing Fashion Writer

The man convicted of murdering fashion writer Christa Worthington is back in a Cape Cod courtroom Friday.

NewsCenter 5's Steve Lacy reported that a judge is trying to see if racism played a part in the jury's decision to convict Christopher McCowen last year. Last week, a judge questioned the 12 jurors in the case.

McCowen's attorney was expected to introduce an expert Friday witness to testify on how racial bias can affect the outcome of a trial. ... WCVB Channel 5

Judge finishes questioning McCown jurors; Decision promised soon; Retrial called likely

Judge finishes questioning jurors about alleged racial bias
Says he "could order a new trial if he found that bias "

A judge finished questioning jurors Friday during an unusual hearing into whether racial bias tainted the conviction of a black trash collector for the murder of a white fashion writer.  After questioning the final five jurors in Barnstable Superior Court, Judge Gary Nickerson called a short recess. It was unclear how the hearing would proceed.

But Nickerson has said he could order a new trial if he found that bias affected the conviction of Christopher McCowen for the rape and fatal stabbing of Christa Worthington at her Cape Cod home in January 2002...   MSNBC. 
__________

Jurors’ Testimony in Cape Cod Murder Ends
McCowen's father attends hearing

“It’s obvious that Chris’s race and size had something to do with their notion that he killed her,”  McCowen's fatherRare juror testimony on whether racial bias tainted a high-profile murder conviction ended here on Friday, leaving the judge alone with the thorny task of deciding whether a new trial is warranted... Judge Nickerson must decide not only whether the statements described in the affidavits were made, but also whether they indicated racial bias. While it is exceedingly rare for judges to call back juries after verdicts and ask what occurred during deliberations, Judge Nickerson’s decision was not without precedent.

Some legal scholars oppose any such hearings, saying that private deliberations are sacrosanct and that opening them to public questioning could have a chilling effect on future jurors.  Some of the McCowen jurors were clearly uncomfortable being called back to court. “I do not in any way apologize for this inconvenience or detour in your lives,” the judge said, “because what is at stake is enormously important to all involved"...

Mr. McCowen’s father, Roy, who traveled from Virginia for the hearing, said he and his son were optimistic that a new trial was on the horizon. Christopher McCowen has said that he had consensual sex with Ms. Worthington, but that a friend of his killed her.  “It’s obvious that Chris’s race and size had something to do with their notion that he killed her,” Roy McCowen said. “They saw a guilty black man before the trial even started"...  New York Times. 
__________

Worthington jurors confirm quarrel
Foreman warned panel that race not relevant, 1 recalls

By the end of an extraordinary two-day hearing yesterday, almost all of the members of the jury that convicted a trash hauler in a notorious slaying on Cape Cod had confirmed that two jurors angrily confronted each other during deliberations after one referred to the defendant as a "big black man."  Whether the loud argument between a black female juror and a white female juror reflected racial strife that tainted the verdict or a misunderstanding about a "descriptive" phrase, however, remains in dispute.

In response to a question by a Barnstable Superior Court judge about the atmosphere in the jury room, one of five jurors who testified yesterday said the foreman, Dan Patenaude, had admonished jurors that Christopher M. McCowen's race was irrelevant - even though McCowen's lawyer said police targeted the defendant partly because he is black.

"We want to make sure that we get this right, totally right; race doesn't come into it," juror Matthew Maltby recalled the foreman saying after one of the jurors had referred to the defendant's race.  "And it didn't," Maltby added...  Globe. 
_________

Cape jury bias probe now in judge’s hands
Experts see likely appeal after ruling

The fate of a black trash hauler convicted of murdering a white fashion writer now rests with a state judge who yesterday ended juror testimony in a rare public hearing to decide whether racial bias tainted the jury’s decision.  Barnstable Superior Court Judge Gary A. Nickerson is facing unchartered legal territory as he weighs whether to grant a new trial to Christopher McCowen.

Legal analysts predict the ruling will be appealed to a higher court, prolonging a sad saga that has captivated Cape Cod since Christa Worthington’s beaten body was found in her Truro home in 2002.  “If there’s even an odor of prejudice in the jury deliberations, they should get a new trial because it was a close case,” said retired Superior Court Judge Robert A. Barton...  Herald. 
__________

Judge finishes questioning jurors about alleged racial bias

A judge finished questioning jurors Friday during an unusual hearing into whether racial bias tainted the conviction of a black trash collector for the murder of a white fashion writer.  After questioning the final five jurors in Barnstable Superior Court, Judge Gary Nickerson called a short recess. It was unclear how the hearing would proceed.  But Nickerson has said he could order a new trial if he found that bias affected the conviction of Christopher McCowen for the rape and fatal stabbing of Christa Worthington at her Cape Cod home in January 2002...  Telegram.   

Juror furor described by major, daily newspapers, could result in new trial for McCowen

Christa furor
Slay Juror Denies Race Bias

By Jack Coleman, New York Post correspondent

A white juror accused of making racially charged comments during deliberations at the Christa Worthington murder trial denied those allegations on the stand yesterday.

Marlo George, who voted to convict Christopher McCowen, testified she never said the bruises on the fashion writer's body were the result of a beating from "a big, black man."

But four other jurors testified they heard her say it.

One of those who took the stand was Roshena Bohanna, the sole African-American on the panel and one of the jurors whose complaints about racial bias motivated Judge Gary Nickerson to conduct the unusual hearing, which could result in him ordering a new trial...  New York POST.
__________

Jurors deny bias fueled verdict
Truro murder trial scrutinized

Three jurors accused in sworn statements of making racially charged remarks before convicting a black trash collector of murdering a white Cape Cod fashion writer yesterday point-blank denied making the disparaging remarks during a daylong hearing rife with contradictory testimony.

The rare judicial inquiry into the jury proceedings that convicted Christopher McCowen of raping and murdering globe-trotting fashionista Christa Worthington in January 2002 exposed starkly conflicting accounts of how race was raised during the six days of juror deliberations in November 2006.

Six jurors answered questions under oath from Barnstable Court Judge Gary Nickerson, who ordered the jury back to court after McCowen’s attorney, Robert George, submitted affidavits from three jurors who claimed race tainted the panel’s deliberations...  Herald.  
__________

McCowen Jurors testify about claims of racism

Terms used like "200-pound black man" and "big black man"Jurors who convicted a black trash collector in 2006 of raping and murdering a white fashion writer on Cape Cod hurled allegations yesterday of racism and inappropriate behavior in an extraordinary court hearing held to determine whether bias tainted the verdict.

In the same courtroom where Christopher M. McCowen was convicted, three jurors took the witness stand and said that another jury member referred to the defendant during deliberations as a "big black man" who would no doubt leave the bruises that were found on the much smaller Christa Worthington.

The accused juror, Marlo George, later took the stand and said that she had referred to McCowen as a "200-pound black man" but said she merely "meant it as descriptive."  As juror after juror took the stand yesterday, seven in all, a picture was painted of a jury in one of the state's highest-profile cases in years riven by racially tainted strife. At one point during deliberations, emotions became so heated that the foreman called for a pause to let passions cool.  Adding to the disharmony, yet another juror testified yesterday that one of the accusing jurors called a different juror a "Southern cracker"...   Globe.  
_________

Jurors in a Cape Cod Murder Case Testify About Racial Remarks

“That’s why I don’t like black people”More than a year after it convicted a black trash hauler of a shocking murder on Cape Cod, a jury returned to court here Thursday for an extraordinary hearing on whether racism influenced its verdict...  Judge Nickerson questioned 7 of the 14 jurors on Thursday, calling them into the courtroom one at a time and asking whether the issue of race came up during their deliberations. Some of the jurors’ answers contradicted those of others, and many said their memories of the deliberations, which took place in November 2006, were vague... 

One of those jurors remarked that the bruises on Ms. Worthington’s body, as seen in evidence photographs, were consistent with “if a big black man hit her,” Ms. Bohanna testified.  The other, Ms. Bohanna said, told her fellow jurors that she feared Mr. McCowen because he was black.  After she confronted those women, Ms. Bohanna added, a male juror who is black admonished her and said, “That’s why I don’t like black people”... New York Times. 

Extraordinary hearing probes role of race; Worthington juror denies alleged bias

Worthington juror denies alleged bias
“Did you say he’s a big black man?” - Judge Gary A. Nickerson

“Did you say he’s a big black man?” asked Superior Court Judge Gary A. Nickerson. "No" said Cahill.

A white female juror who was accused by a fellow panelist of making racially charged remarks about a black man convicted of killing Christa Worthington denied displaying racial bias about the defendant during the trial.  The woman, who is referred to as Juror X in an affidavit signed by three other panelists, testified today that she never referred to Christopher McCowen’s race.

“I said that the defendant made me uncomfortable or intimidated,” said Carol Cahill, who is the first juror to take the stand following testimony from the three jurors who gave sworn statements...  After the trial, McCowen’s attorney, Robert George, filed affidavits in which three jurors said other panelists referred to McCowen as “an intimidating, big black man.”  Under questioning from Nickerson, Cahill reviewed portions of those statements that describe racially charged remarks from jurors. She denied making the remarks attributed to her...  Herald. 
__________

An extraordinary hearing probes role of race in Cape murder trial

"This is an extraordinarily unusual situation, when a court makes inquiry of jurors after the delivery of a verdict."
    - Judge Nickerson.A member of a Cape Cod jury that convicted a black trash collector of murder in 2006 testified today in an unusual court hearing that her fellow jurors had made racially insensitive remarks during the trial.

Roshena Bohanna, who is black, said she had heard the remarks, both directly and indirectly, before jury deliberations, during deliberations, and even when the jury was sequestered at a hotel.  She said that she had gotten into such a heated confrontation with a white juror over one remark that the jury foreman had to call for a break in the deliberations...  Globe. 
__________

Worthington jurors back in court

The Christa Worthington murder case is back in Barnstable Superior Court today. Judge Gary Nickerson will question jurors about alleged racism during their deliberations 14 months ago.

Back then, Christopher McCowen was convicted of rape and first degree murder. He's now serving a life sentence. But that could change with today's public hearing. ... Listen to Real Audio at WBUR.org

___________________________ 

Judge to question jurors about alleged bias in deliberations

Jurors that convicted a Cape Cod man of murdering fashion writer Christa Worthington are being asked to testify publicly about whether racism infected their deliberations.

In a highly unusual move, Superior Court Judge Gary Nickerson convenes a hearing Thursday that could determine whether Christopher McCowen, a black garbage collector, receives a new trial.

Within three days of McCowen’s November 2006 conviction, three jurors contacted his lawyer and claimed to have heard racially biased remarks from three other jurors — including one who allegedly referred to McCowen as "the big black guy." ... Boston Herald

Hypnotizing a potential witness - Worthington's daughter

The idea makes you cringe, doesn't it? Me too, until I thought about it. Then I went from cringing to wondering if it's an inherently bad idea.

There is a potential witness to the murder of Christa Worthington in January 2002 at her isolated Truro bungalow - Worthington's daughter, Ava, who was 2 years old when her mother died.

But how could Ava's memory of this horrific incident, assuming she has any, be unlocked? Speaking for myself, the earliest memories begin around age 4, vague ones at that. A few earlier ones may kick around upstairs, but I can't be sure if they are genuine, or fragments of dreams, or recollection of events I wish had occurred but actually didn't.

Supposedly, distant memories from toddlerhood and even infancy can resurface - through hypnosis. This is not something I've ever seen, nor have I been hypnotized. But I've read about it enough the years, of people recalling in exact detail the circumstances of  birthday parties when they were toddlers, what everyone was wearing, the gifts that were given, the weather. I've also noticed the persistent appearance of ads for quitting smoking or losing weight to believe there might be something there.

Consider also that some people refuse to be hypnotized, for fear of what will surface or be suggested while they are in a trance.

This is not something Ava, now of elementary school age, could decide for herself until she was at least a decade older. It would be for her guardians to consider, though I doubt they will.

But if I were in their shoes, I'd consider it at that point when the child in my guardian care was mature enough to understand the implications. And if the practitioner could assure me that my child would possess no conscious memory of being hypnotized.

Another question comes to mind - what good can come of this, especially considering the risk of revisiting such trauma? Would any of it, assuming any could be summoned through hypnosis and recorded, be admissable in court?

Probably not, though perhaps someone better acquainted with the law could correct me if I'm wrong.

But two reasons come to mind for the possibility that Ava may remember what happened the night her mother died, even if the memory is buried far below the surface.

As anyone familiar with this case can attest, Worthington is unlikely to have gone gently into that good night. No, she raged and fought, not only for herself, but to protect her child. There is hardly a woman alive who wouldn't do the same to protect her cub.

Clearly there was a desperate struggle outside, the door kicked in and Worthington stabbed to death on the kitchen floor by the stairs leading to the second floor, where Ava was presumably sleeping - at least until she heard the screaming. Those of us who've raised children know what little noise it takes to awaken a 2-year-old.

The second reason I believe Ava may remember what happened has to do with something she allegedly said at the wake for her mother in Hingham, according to a reporter from New York magazine who managed to get inside the funeral home.

"Parading around in a green velvet dress topped by a Peter Pan collar, Ava smiled a wide Worthington smile as she navigated the crowd," wrote Vanessa Grigoriadis in the Feb. 4, 2002 issue of New York. "Ava is now living with Cliff and Amyra Chase, the Cohasset couple designated as her guardians in Worthington's will, which bequeaths $700,000 to the child.

"' 'Yesterday,' clucked one of her babysitters, watching her, 'Ava went into the corner of the room and said six times, loud and clear, 'Get out of my house, I'm not afraid of you.' Six times she said it.' "

Yeah, I know, 2-year-olds say all sorts of things and back when my daughter and son were that age, I took most of it with a grain of salt. But considering when this was supposedly said, it's much tougher to dismiss with a shrug.

(photo credit, ultimatestateofmind.co.uk)

McCowen wants new trial - claims real murderer was Frazier

Cape Cod Fashion Writer's Murderer Requests New Trial
McCowen claims prosecutors withheld key evidence about Frazier

The trash collector convicted in the fatal stabbing of a fashion writer from Truro claims prosecutors withheld key evidence in his case. Christopher McCowen (in composite photo from the trial on right facing Jeremy Frazier)  is seeking a new trial.  His lawyer argues in a court motion that prosecutors withheld evidence that a man McCowen says was the real killer of Christa Worthington was once arrested for threatening to kill two British tourists with a knife.

McCowen's lawyer says if jurors had known Jeremy Frazier used a knife in another crime, it could have bolstered McCowen's claim that it was Frazier who stabbed Worthington in January 2002...  Fox-TV.  

Jury in Cape murder ordered back to court
In an extraordinary hearing scheduled Jan. 10 and 11 at Barnstable Superior Court, each of the jurors - including a woman who will be flown in from Texas - will be questioned under oath in open court by a judge about whether racially insensitive remarks allegedly made during more than a week of deliberations tainted the verdict against Christopher M. McCowen.
   Superior Court Judge Gary A. Nickerson ordered the hearing after McCowen's lawyer asked for a new trial, based on sworn statements from three jurors who contacted him within days of the November 2006 conviction. The jurors said three other jurors made repeated racist remarks, at one point almost triggering a fight...  Globe. 

Read these stories from capecodtoday's archives about Frazier:

• Read from our trial reports; "...During the six-hour interrogation that followed, according to police testimony, McCowen gave an evolving series of accounts of the night of Worthington's death, culminating with his claim that a friend of McCowen's, Jeremy Frazier, stabbed her.  Testifying during the trial, Frazier denied killing Worthington and no evidence was presented linking him to the scene. "
•  As false confessions go, not a very good one: "...All of which is tantamount to alleging police corruption -- along with abject bigotry -- while avoiding those actual words. But ask yourself -- if police are willing and capable of what George is claiming, of compounding the tragedy of a brutal murder by railroading an innocent man and sending him to prison for life, an act comparable to murder in and of itself, why would they introduce a second suspect -- Jeremy Frazier -- when this has the potential to blow their case out of the water?..." 
  

• Those problematic fibers; "... Richard Saferstein (defense expert) also pointed out that white and blue fibers found on Worthington's genital area were not tested by the crime lab -- and as those who followed the trial are aware, Jeremy Frazier, the Wellfleet man alleged by McCowen to have killed Worthington, was wearing a white and blue sweater on the night the prosecution believes Worthington was murdered...
     "But Frazier was not the only person wearing white on the night of the murder. So was McCowen, who can be seen clad in white pants on video footage taken at the Juice Bar. And that fibers from Frazier's sweater could have transferred to McCowen's clothing, and then to Worthington, is hardly beyond the realm of possibility..."

• Defense lawyer in Cape Cod slaying known for aggressive style; "...When a black trash collector was arrested in the killing of a well-known fashion writer in her Cape Cod home, some thought the police had a slam dunk.Christopher McCowen's DNA was found on the battered body of Christa Worthington, and he allegedly told police he helped a friend beat her. Although McCowen insisted that it was his friend, Jeremy Frazier, who killed Worthington by plunging a knife into her chest, police believed McCowen acted alone.... 

• The mysterious 12:03 a.m. phone call from state police;  "...And with a retrial, one of the holes in the prosecution's case to be patched is the mysterious phone call to Jeremy Frazier from the Yarmouth state police barracks at 12:03 a.m. on Saturday Jan. 4, 2002.   Defense attorney Robert George made frequent references to the call as part of a broad strategy of raising doubts about the state's case against accused killer Christopher McCowen. Frazier, when he testified, denied receiving any call from state police that night, nor that he had any relationship with police..."

Reasonable doubt about a verdict

Readers over a certain age may remember a great television series of the mid-70s called "Ellery Queen" based on the literary crime sleuth. The title character was played by the late Jim Hutton, father of actor Timothy Hutton. Each week's show would revolve around a murder mystery and Queen's efforts to solve it, which he'd invariably do at the end of every episode upon noticing a previously seen but seemingly innocuous clue.

That's it, Queen would say, turning to the camera and addressing the viewer. And if you paid attention, you figured it out too. After a commercial break, the show would return with all the major players assembled and Queen would explain whodunit, and why.

Would that real life and actual murder mysteries played out so tidily. A year ago in Barnstable village, a Superior Court jury began deliberating the fate of a 34-year-old Hyannis trash hauler, Christopher McCowen (seen at right being escorted from court), accused in the brutal stabbing death and rape of Christa Worthington, 46, a former fashion writer and single mother in Truro.

In the year since the trial, I've wondered - had there been a seemingly innocuous piece of evidence or testimony that, if held to the light at the right angle, would become a Rosetta Stone unraveling the mystery?

Based on what I saw and heard while covering the trial as a stringer for the New York Post and blogging about it here, there was no such clue, at least not for me. But there's one that came close - the mysterious driver barreling out of Worthington's driveway on the afternoon of Jan. 5, 2002, the day before her body was discovered.

Testifying during the trial, Truro resident Girard Smith said he saw a "large dark vehicle" speeding down Worthington's driveway between 1 and 3 p.m. on Jan. 5. The vehicle came within 15 feet of him, Smith testified, and was driven so fast it could easily have crashed into another vehicle.

Did you see the driver, Smith was asked on the stand. Yes, he was a white male in his late 30s, early 40s - which means it could not be McCowen, who is black. 

Don't get me wrong, this hardly proves McCowen is innocent, nor is it proof the driver in such a hurry had anything to do with Worthington's death.  But when combined with another aspect of the case, it allows for the unsettling possibility that McCowen did not murder Worthington or did not act alone as alleged by the prosecution.

Early in the trial, on Oct. 23, 2006, pathologist Henry Nields testified that Worthington "had likely been dead for 24 to 36 hours when a colleague from the state medical examiner's office examined her at the crime scene," as reported by Court TV (that colleague, Dr. James Weiner, was too ill during the trial to testify).

Weiner arrived at the Worthington house around 8 p.m. on Sunday, Jan. 6, according to testimony during the trial. Extrapolating back with the timeframe of 24 to 36 hours to the time of Worthington's death, this means she was most likely murdered between 8 p.m. and 8 a.m. on Saturday, Jan. 5.  And smack dab in the middle of that timeframe is when Smith saw a vehicle high-tailing it out of Worthington's driveway, presumably with an extremely agitated driver. And the driver seen by Smith was white, not black - and could not have been McCowen.

Again, what Smith witnessed doesn't prove anything beyond his credible description of it. But Smith's testimony does allow for reasonable inferences. Such as - it is reasonable to infer that the person driving the vehicle was aware of, if not involved in, Worthington's death. It is reasonable to infer that the person driving the vehicle was fleeing from the scene in a panic because he was implicated in Worthington's death, either by direct involvement or covering up after the fact. And it is reasonable to infer of at least the possibility that Worthington was murdered on the afternoon of Jan. 5 and not the night before by McCowen, as the prosecution claimed and jurors ultimately agreed.

Eight months after Worthington's death, I attended a journalism conference in Maine with several of my colleagues from the Cape Cod Times, where the paper was honored with several awards, including one I received for investigative reporting. The guest speaker at the opening night dinner was author Dominick Dunne, who spoke mainly about the conviction earlier that year of Michael Skakel for the October 1975 bludgeoning death of 15-year-old Martha Moxley.

The Moxley case was not one I'd followed but Dunne's remarks - and the man is a consummate raconteur - piqued my interest. The Moxleys and the Skakels had lived only a block apart in Greenwich, Conn., and Dunne described how Dorothy Moxley, Martha's mother, told him of the anguish she suffered for years whenever she drove past the the Skakel house (she eventually moved out of the neighborhood).

Every time Mrs. Moxley saw the house, Dunne recounted, she thought that maybe the person who killed her daughter did not live there, but the people in the house knew who did. And that was almost as bad.

I think the same can be said of the driver of the vehicle witnessed by Smith. His presence at the scene hardly proves the man committed murder, whoever he is. But it sure as hell looks like he knows who did.

(photo credit, washingtonpost.com)

No decision by Worthington trial judge for hearing on alleged racism among jurors

Update, 4:30 p.m. -  

Barnstable Superior Court Judge Gary Nickerson has taken no action on a motion filed by defense attorney Robert George alleging racial bias among jurors in last fall's murder trial of Christopher McCowen, who was convicted of killing Truro resident Christa Worthington in January 2002.

 Nickerson held a hearing on the motion this morning with George and assistant district attorney Lisa Edmonds, but did not come to a decision or set a date for another hearing, according to clerk magistrate Scott Nickerson.  

George filed the motion  in January asserting that at least three jurors made racial remarks during their week-long deliberations at the end of the trial.

The jury convicted McCowen of first-degree murder, aggravated rape and aggravated burglary. McCowen, Worthington's trash hauler, was sentenced to life in prison without chance of parole, a mandatory punishment for conviction of first-degree murder in Massachusetts. A first-degree murder conviction also triggers an automatic appeal.

Edmonds replaces original prosecutor Robert Welch III, who was nominated for a judgeship by then-Gov. Mitt Romney in the closing days of the Worthington trial. Welch has since been sworn in as a district court associate justice.

Worthington, 46, a former fashion writer, was found stabbed to death in her isolated bungalow by a former boyfriend on Jan. 6, 2002, a day after she was attacked. Her 2-year-old daughter, Ava, was also found, unharmed. 

McCowen, first questioned by police two months after the murder, denied any physical contact with Worthington, according to police testimony during the trial. 

A DNA link proving that McCowen had sexual contact with Worthington prior to her death led to McCowen's arrest in April 2005. During the six-hour interrogation that followed, according to police testimony, McCowen gave an evolving series of accounts of the night of Worthington's death, culminating with his claim that a friend of McCowen's, Jeremy Frazier, stabbed her.

Testifying during the trial, Frazier denied killing Worthington and no evidence was presented linking him to the scene.